Two estimates. One claim. Someone has to settle it.

Your insurance company priced the repair one way. Your contractor priced it another. Almost every property policy contains an appraisal clause written for exactly this moment — and it works, if you have someone who knows how to use it.

Serving the Front Range from Fort Collins to Pueblo.

12 years in property claims Appraiser & umpire $1,200 flat residential fee Hail, wind, water, fire Both sides — carrier and policyholder

For roofers, public adjusters & attorneys

When the claim is stuck on the number, bring in an independent appraiser.

The estimate is written, the supplement is in, the negotiation has stalled. When the dispute is over scope or price rather than coverage, the policy already has a way to settle it: the appraisal clause. Send me the file and I'll tell you honestly whether it's an appraisal case.

  • Roofers & contractors: have the scope you wrote priced line by line. Appraisal puts your estimate in front of two appraisers, and an umpire if needed, so you're not the one arguing the claim. Colorado limits what contractors can negotiate on a homeowner's behalf; appraisal keeps you on the right side of that line.
  • Public adjusters: an independent appraiser when negotiation stalls. When you've taken the claim as far as negotiation will go, invoke appraisal and I serve as the insured's appraiser. You stay on the claim; the amount gets decided.
  • Attorneys: a neutral appraisal and award on disputed loss amounts. For first-party files where the fight is quantum, not coverage, I take appraiser and umpire appointments and write estimates built to hold up under scrutiny.
  • Missing scope gets priced line by line. The carrier's appraiser isn't bound by the carrier's internal estimating guidelines, so items left off the carrier's estimate get a real look.
  • Weeks, not months of re-inspections. Most files go from invoking the clause to a signed award in about one to three months.
  • One flat fee, your call who pays. $1,200 flat residential fee. The roofer, public adjuster, or attorney who brings me the file can cover it, or have the homeowner pay. Never a percentage of the award. Commercial is quoted in writing.
  • No referral fees, either way. I don't pay or take them, and I have no stake in the repair or the size of the award. Who pays the fee is disclosed in writing up front. That keeps the award clean.

How it works

  1. Send the file. The carrier estimate, the competing estimate or supplement, and the gap between them. I review it at no charge.
  2. Straight answer. If it's a scope or pricing dispute, appraisal fits. If it's a coverage denial, I'll say so and you won't waste time.
  3. Appraisal is invoked. The insured names me as appraiser, and the flat $1,200 residential fee is agreed in writing, covered by you or by the homeowner, whichever you choose. I handle the inspection, the line-by-line with the carrier's appraiser, and the award.

Send me a stuck claim

Two minutes. I'll review it at no charge and call you back.

Optional. PDF works best; keep it small (a few MB). Bigger files: email them after you submit.

Reviewing a file doesn't create an engagement. The insured names the appraiser; the fee agreement is in writing before work starts.

The part most people have never read

Your policy already has a way out of this argument.

Open your policy and look for the word appraisal. Nearly every property policy in Colorado has a clause saying that when the insurer and the policyholder disagree on the amount of a loss, either side can demand appraisal.

Here's how it resolves. You name an appraiser. Your insurance company names theirs. The two of them inspect the property, compare scope and pricing line by line, and negotiate to a number. If they can't agree, a neutral umpire decides. The result is binding on the amount.

What makes it work is simple: the appraiser your carrier names is not bound by the carrier's internal estimating guidelines. The conversation moves out of the desk adjuster's queue and into a room with two people who actually build estimates for a living.

Appraisal settles how much the loss costs. It does not decide whether the loss is covered — that's a separate question, and I'll tell you honestly if it's the one you actually have.

It's faster than litigation, it costs a fraction as much, and in most cases it doesn't require an attorney at all. Each side pays its own appraiser and splits the umpire's fee.

The catch is that it only works if the person you name knows how carrier estimates are built, where scope routinely goes missing, and how to document the difference in terms the other appraiser can't wave away. That's the job.

A question I get constantly

Public adjuster, or appraisal?

Public adjusters do real work, and plenty of claims need one — a loss that has to be documented and filed from scratch, or a claim too large and tangled to manage on your own. If that's where you are, hire one. I'll tell you so myself.

But there's one situation where appraisal is clearly the better instrument: the claim is already filed, coverage isn't in question, and the only problem is that your contractor's estimate and the carrier's estimate are thousands of dollars apart. Here's why.

A public adjuster negotiates. Appraisal decides.

However good your public adjuster is, they're still negotiating with the same carrier, through the same adjuster, inside the same estimating system that produced the number you're disputing. Nothing forces a conclusion. The appraisal clause does: two appraisers, an umpire if they can't agree, and an award that is binding on the amount.

It gets your file out of the queue.

The appraiser your carrier names is not bound by that carrier's internal estimating guidelines. Your claim stops being a line on a desk adjuster's screen and becomes a conversation between two people who build estimates for a living, standing on your roof.

The fee doesn't grow with your claim.

Public adjusters in Colorado generally charge 5–15% of the entire settlement — fair enough when they've carried the whole claim. My rate is a $1,200 flat residential fee, never a percentage of the award, no matter what the claim turns out to be worth. The roofer, public adjuster, or attorney who brings me the file can cover it, or have the homeowner pay. Commercial files are quoted in writing.

If the claim settles at Public adjuster at 10% Front Range Appraisal
$25,000$2,500$1,200
$50,000$5,000$1,200
$75,000$7,500$1,200
$100,000$10,000$1,200

None of that makes a public adjuster the wrong choice — it makes them the wrong choice for this particular problem. When a claim needs building from the ground up, a percentage of the settlement is money well spent. When the claim is sound and only the number is wrong, appraisal is the mechanism your policy already gave you, and the fee is the same either way.

Who I work with

Homeowners, the contractors on their roof, and the attorneys who get called when it stalls.

Homeowners

Your roof was denied, underpaid, or approved for a repair that won't hold. You've been passed between adjusters for months. I'll read your estimate, tell you plainly whether appraisal is the right tool, and serve as your appraiser if it is.

Roofers & restoration contractors

You supplemented, you sent the photos, and the desk adjuster still won't move. Rather than eating the difference or walking the job, point your customer toward appraisal. I document the full scope and price it accurately; when the award reflects what the roof actually needs, you can build it. You keep the customer relationship. How it works for contractors.

Attorneys

For first-party property files where the dispute is quantum rather than coverage, appraisal often resolves it faster and cheaper than motion practice. I take appraiser and umpire appointments and write estimates that hold up under scrutiny.

How it actually goes

From the first call to a signed award.

Timelines vary by carrier and by how complicated the loss is. This is the shape of it.

We look at what you already have

Send me the carrier's estimate, your contractor's estimate, and the denial or payment letter. No charge for this. Sometimes the answer is that appraisal isn't your problem — a coverage denial needs a different approach, and I'd rather tell you that up front than take a file I can't move.

You invoke the appraisal clause

A written demand goes to your carrier naming me as your appraiser. I'll prepare it and walk you through what it says before you send it.

The carrier names its appraiser

In my experience this usually lands within a couple of weeks. Colorado has disclosure rules both appraisers have to follow about prior involvement and any financial interest in the outcome — I comply with them, and I'll explain what they mean for your file.

Both appraisers inspect and compare

We walk the property together, agree on what's damaged, and then work through scope and pricing line by line. This is where most claims resolve, because the other appraiser is no longer constrained by the carrier's estimating platform.

Agreement, or an umpire

When the two appraisers agree, they sign an award and the carrier pays per the policy. When they don't, a neutral umpire reviews both positions and breaks the tie. Any two of the three signing makes the award.

Start at step one. Send me the two estimates and I'll tell you what I see.

Submit your request here

Who you'd be working with

Matthew Rau

I've spent twelve years inside property insurance claims — field adjusting hail, wind, water, and fire losses for carriers and independent adjusting firms. I came into appraisal work through one of the better appraisers in the business, starting in Dallas, and have handled files in Texas, Minnesota, and Colorado since.

Most of my appraisal work has been on the carrier side. I'm telling you that deliberately, because it's the reason I'm useful to a homeowner: I know how these estimates get built, what gets left out, and which arguments actually move a file. I've also sat as umpire when two appraisers couldn't close the gap.

I'll give you a straight read on your claim, including when the honest answer is that you don't have one.

Based in
Denver, Colorado
Experience
12 years in property insurance claims
Loss types
Hail, wind, water, fire, catastrophe
Roles
Policyholder appraiser, carrier appraiser, umpire
Fee
$1,200 flat residential, covered by the referring roofer, public adjuster or attorney, or by the homeowner; commercial quoted in writing

$1,200 flat residential fee. The roofer, public adjuster, or attorney who brings me the file can cover it, or have the homeowner pay. Never a percentage of the award. Commercial files are quoted in writing before any engagement. Under the appraisal clause each side covers its own appraiser and the umpire's fee is split.

Where I work

Up and down the Front Range.

Based in Denver and covering the corridor. If you're outside it, call anyway — travel is often workable on larger losses.

DenverAuroraLakewoodArvadaWestminsterThorntonCentennialLittletonHighlands RanchEnglewoodGoldenParkerCastle RockBroomfieldBoulderLouisvilleLongmontLovelandFort CollinsGreeleyColorado SpringsPueblo

Questions people ask first

Straight answers.

Are you a public adjuster?

No, and the difference matters enough that I've set it out side by side above. Short version: a public adjuster manages your whole claim as your advocate, usually for a percentage of the settlement. An appraiser is named under the appraisal clause to determine the amount of the loss, is required to act impartially once appointed, and charges a flat fee here. Colorado takes that distinction seriously, including rules about disclosing prior involvement in a claim. If what you need is a public adjuster, I'll say so and point you to one.

How is appraisal different from suing my insurance company?

Appraisal is built into your policy, so it doesn't require a lawsuit, a filing fee, or usually an attorney. It resolves one question — how much the loss costs — and it typically takes weeks rather than years. If your dispute is about whether the damage is covered at all, appraisal is the wrong tool, and that's a conversation for an attorney.

Can you guarantee I'll get more money?

No, and be wary of anyone who does. An appraiser's job is to determine the amount of the loss accurately, and an appraiser who promises an outcome before seeing the property has told you something about their impartiality. What I can tell you is whether the gap between the two estimates looks like a scope and pricing problem that appraisal is designed to fix.

What does it cost?

The first conversation and a look at your paperwork are free. If we move forward, residential appraisals are $1,200 flat, in writing before anything starts. The roofer, public adjuster, or attorney who brought you to me can cover it, or you pay it. It's never a percentage of the award. Commercial losses are quoted in writing up front. Under the policy, each side covers its own appraiser and the two sides split the umpire's fee if one is needed.

My contractor told me to call. Does that create a conflict?

Referrals from roofers and restoration contractors are normal and they're where a lot of my work comes from. What matters is that I have no financial interest in the repair itself or the size of the award. I don't take referral fees and I don't get a percentage. Sometimes the roofer, public adjuster, or attorney who refers the file covers my flat fee instead of the homeowner; when that happens it's disclosed in writing, and the fee is the same whatever the award turns out to be. Colorado's disclosure rules cover exactly this, and I follow them.

How long does the whole thing take?

From invoking the clause to a signed award, most files land somewhere between one and three months. The carrier naming its appraiser is usually a couple of weeks. After that, the pace depends on scheduling the joint inspection and how far apart the two estimates really are. Umpire involvement adds time.

Do you take carrier-side and umpire appointments?

Yes. Most of my appraisal work to date has been carrier-side, and I've served as umpire. If you're a carrier, TPA, or attorney looking for an appraiser or umpire on a Colorado file, get in touch.

Get in touch

Send me your estimate.

The fastest way to find out whether you have an appraisal case is to let someone read the two estimates side by side. Upload your carrier's estimate and your contractor's with the form and I'll go through them. That costs you nothing.

Call or text(760) 845-1171 EmailMattrau27@outlook.com

Attach your paperwork

Optional, but it's the fastest way to get a real answer. PDFs work best; photos of printed pages are fine. Keep the total under about 7 MB — if your files are bigger, send just the carrier estimate here and I'll reply with an email address for the rest.

The scope or payment sheet your carrier sent, and the denial letter if you got one.

Whatever your roofer or restoration contractor wrote up, including any supplement.

Your policy declarations page, engineer's report, or photos of the damage.

Your documents are sent over an encrypted connection and used only to review your claim. Sending this doesn't create a working relationship and nothing here is legal advice. If your claim involves a coverage denial rather than a disagreement about amount, you may need an attorney — I'll tell you if that's what I see.